From $43K to $90K Water Claim Recovery
How PALCO Claims more than doubled an under-scoped water-damage claim through detailed documentation and appraisal.
Initial estimate under-scoped the repairs and missed key approved items.
Binding appraisal award, more than double the carrier’s original estimate.
Interior water damage from December 2025.
Single-family home in the Greater Austin area, Texas.
The carrier valued the loss at only $43,063.51. The estimate under-scoped the reconstruction, left out already-approved water mitigation, and proposed to clean and regrout damaged tile floors instead of replacing them.
That scope fell short of what was needed to properly repair the kitchen, bathrooms, bedrooms, flooring, and other damaged interior areas.
Through appraisal, PALCO Claims helped secure a binding award of $90,165.64 in replacement cost value and $76,630.51 in actual cash value.
≈ $47,000 in additional recovery. The final award came in at roughly 2.1x the carrier’s original estimate.
The Challenge
After a water loss damaged much of the home’s interior, including the kitchen, bathrooms, bedrooms, and flooring, the homeowner’s carrier issued an estimate of just $43,063.51.
That number did not fully reflect the cost of proper reconstruction. It also left out water mitigation that had already been approved and treated damaged tile floors as a cleaning and regrouting issue instead of a replacement issue.
The homeowner needed a stronger claim file, clearer documentation, and support through the appraisal process.
How PALCO Helped
PALCO Claims stepped in as the homeowner’s advocate with no upfront cost and built a stronger appraisal file.
Prepared a detailed, room-by-room replacement estimate for the damaged interior areas.
Backed the estimate with a measured sketch and full photo report.
Identified what the carrier’s scope missed, including already-approved water mitigation.
Disputed under-scoped repair items, including full tile-floor replacement versus a “clean and regrout” approach.
Invoked the policy’s appraisal provision and served as the homeowner’s appraiser.
Presented the documentation through a joint inspection and worked the claim to a binding appraisal award.
Guided the homeowner on re-engaging the carrier for payment after the appraisal award.
The Outcome
The binding appraisal award came in at $90,165.64 in replacement cost value and $76,630.51 in actual cash value.
That was more than double the carrier’s original $43,063.51 estimate and created roughly $47,000 in additional recovery for the homeowner.
The claim was settled, and the homeowner was funded to complete the repairs.
Proven Results
PALCO helped turn an under-scoped water claim into a stronger appraisal recovery.
$43,063.51
Initial carrier estimate
$90,165.64
Final binding appraisal award
≈ $76,630.51
Actual cash value
Denied or underpaid claim?
PALCO works on contingency — you pay nothing unless we
recover for you. Get a free consultation today.